Accidents Halved As Street is Stripped of Safety Features
It started in Holland and has now spread to the UK. I am willing to bet that none of the risk averse professional engineers who command our streets will be willing to risk trying it here. The entire professional ethos of the PEng is not to step out of the conventional way of doing things.
The whole point of the exercise is to change expectations. Drivers are forced to think about that they are doing. How many collisions occur because the driver is convinced that because he was doing what the sign says he was justified in ignoring everything else? How often have you heard the excuse “I didn’t see you!” – of course not, you were not looking for me.
the number of accidents in Kensington High Street has fallen from 71 a year to just 40 a drop of nearly 44 per cent. Accident levels on comparable roads across London have fallen by only 17.5 per cent, an internal council study shows. Since the scheme was completed in September 2003, the number of pedestrians hurt has fallen from 26 a year to nine.
…
Today the scheme’s champion, Councillor Daniel Moylan, said it would be copied nationwide.
“We are having visitors from all over the UK and indeed from overseas and they all want to produce their own versions,” he said. “It is about re-establishing eye contact between road users. They are now looking at each other instead of just signs” The report says vehicle speeds have fallen and drivers appear “more alert to the presence of pedestrians and that they cross the street over its whole length”.
UPDATE July 26
I got a message in email from CITE (Canadian Institute of Transportation Engineers) about Walk21 Toronto 2007
Walk21 Toronto is excited to feature reknowned traffic engineer, Hans Monderman of the Netherlands, as a keynote speaker on Wednesday morning. Monderman is recognized as a pioneer of the ’shared space’ approach to designing streets. This innovative approach, often referred to as naked streets, is designed to create spaces where pedestrians, cyclists and drivers are considered equal, by removing the traditional traffic safety devices such as traffic lights, stop signs, traffic signs, lane markings and sometimes curbs. The result is safer streets where drivers and pedestrians respond to their environment rather than the “rules of the road”. Initially ridiculed, Monderman’s traffic design ideas are now imitated around the world. Hans’s presentation will be followed by a lively discussion on the shared space and naked streets. For more information about this concept visit the European Union sponsored Shared Space project.
So maybe my jeremiad about engineers will not come true and we may see something happening – if not in this region, somewhere in Canada. The conference is in October but the “early bird” savings end at the end of this month.








I’m glad to be reminded about this experiment and to see some followup numbers. It reminds me of my visits to Europe, and how I’m always impressed by the ongoing and peaceful negotiation of the more narrow streets shared by pedestrians and vehicles. Pedestrians in these streets are unintimidated and courteous, casually moving out of the way for cars and scooters; vehicle drivers seem patient and unaggressive – I know there are bound to be exceptions, as everyone has bad days, but to my eyes the need to share space and be aware of each other produces great results.
To be fair to Vancouver, it reminds me of how on many streets, drivers will still stop for pedestrians without being coerced/surprised by those brave enough to just walk out into the street. That little bit of civility does wonders for one’s day.
Todd Sieling
July 26, 2007 at 10:02 am
Do NOT try this is Richmond. Even in parking lots. Especially when on sidewalks that cross entrances to car parks, and even when on marked pedestrian crossings when other traffic has already stopped. “Civility” is not part of the lexicon of drivers in this suburb. While there are a few courteous, patient drivers they are very much in the minority. Always make eye contact with the driver of any moving – or stationary – vehicle before crossing in front of them.
Stephen Rees
July 26, 2007 at 10:18 am
I should have noted for general safety – I dwell in central Vancouver, and eye contact is still needed even when people slow down for you.
Todd Sieling
July 26, 2007 at 1:15 pm
Many times, eye contact is impossible (sunglasses, glare on the windshield. etc.). No wonder people don’t cross even after I’ve stopped for them and smiled at them.
Sungsu
July 26, 2007 at 9:42 pm