Ontario Introduces Green Stimulus Funds
Ontario has a real Liberal government. BC currently has a government that has hijacked the Liberal brand but is in fact deeply conservative – in fact they are essentially a re-tread of the old Social Credit Party – or at least the right wing of that party. They are still stuck in the old blacktop politics that both parties espouse.
In Ontario the provincial budget espoused a Green shift
“jurisdictions that embrace the shift to a low-carbon, sustainable economy — aligning environmental goals with economic ones — will see more robust growth, more jobs and higher wages.”
And part of that is $2.6bn for transit projects in Toronto. Note the difference. BC commits to spending $3bn on an expanded freeway – but it is not in the budget. It is an afterthought after an unfundable P3 collapses – thought the partners in that project still are in line to get the lion’s share of the profits they would have gathered under the P3, and without taking on any of the risk. It seems, like The Producers, sometimes promoting a flop can be more profitable than promoting a hit.
BC has not, of course, done anything very significant to shift to a low carbon, sustainable economy. The big headlines here are for the money being made from oil and gas licenses, the hugely profitable privatisation of power generation (mainly for export to California) and the Olympics. There has been very little emphasis on the carbon tax, as even though it is too small to make any difference is still a distinctly unpopular move in the “heartland” (another word we no longer hear as often). The hydrogen highway has not been forgotten – but probably should be as there are still hardly any hydrogen cars. There are promises of transit investment – but for many year hence, and are also not fundable as they need both federal and regional contributions. The region cannot even fund current transit operation – and the Minister of Transport has even said that he doubts Translink will get new funding sources.
Fortunately there is going to be an opportunity to change the government soon. The question in my mind is “Is the NDP different enough?” I thought the switch of policy to favour the highway widening was bad – but the most recent Vaughan Palmer story has Carol James offering tax cuts to the B.C. Business Council. Both mainstream parties are busy fighting to grab hold of the centre – both being overly confident that they can hold their own side of the spectrum. I wonder about that. What I hear is that people are increasingly dissatisfied with both parties – and think it is time for some new ideas. I can understand those who say the only way to get rid of the Liberals is to hold your nose and vote for the NDP, but sadly they will take that as an endorsement for an approach which is not based on principles but on opportunism.
We already know that you cannot trust Gordon Campbell. He ran on a promise not to sell off BC Rail and then he did exactly that. That process is still before the courts – but related material about Patrick Kinsella a well connected Liberal insider shows that it was far from honest or open. The fix was in – and it was a politically driven fix. CP withdrew and Omnitrax was only kept in by promises of a “consolation prize” – subsequently withdrawn. On his tv show last night Palmer was careful not to talk about matters that are sub judice – but pointed to those who were in court and are writing about it.
Carol James does not seem to be able to convince people that she could run the province – and appears to be doing what many left wing leaders do in those circumstance. She is trying to be “reasonable” – or, in other words, shift right. Tony Blair made a great electoral success out of that in Britain – and out Thatchered Thatcher. I worry that something similar could be on the cards here if she wins. Is there a real choice here?